The Inspector General of Police and the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) have opposed an application by Nairobi lawyer Abshir Ahmedsadak Abdi and his friend Ayub Maalim seeking to stop police from arresting and charging them with criminal offences.
The development comes as the two men appeared before Justice Alexander Muteti at the Milimani High Court on Friday, November 13, following their disappearance nearly two weeks ago.
Abshir and Maalim, who were allegedly abducted on November 1, resurfaced in Marsabit County on Thursday, November 12, bringing an end to days of uncertainty over their whereabouts.
Their appearance marked a significant development in proceedings arising from an application filed by Zakaria Abshir against the State Law Office, the National Police Service Commission (NPSC) and 16 other respondents.
The case, filed under reference HCCRMISCAPPL/E268/2026, seeks answers over Abshir's disappearance and the steps taken by state agencies to trace him.
During Friday's proceedings, the applicants' lawyer, Abner Collins Mangu, argued that the discovery of the two men should not bring the matter to an end.
Mangu told Justice Muteti that the court must establish who was responsible for their disappearance, regardless of whether police or other state agencies acknowledge having held them.
He maintained that even if the respondents prove Abshir and Maalim were never in their custody, questions surrounding their disappearance must still be answered.
According to Mangu, failure to identify those responsible would raise serious concerns about the ability of state institutions to fulfil their constitutional obligation to protect citizens.
The court was also expected to hear directly from Abshir and Maalim about the circumstances surrounding their alleged abduction, detention and eventual release.
Earlier, former Law Society of Kenya president Eric Theuri told the court that both men were ready to testify.
"My Lord, the subject Abshir is now in court and his colleague Ayub Maalim is also before the court," Theuri said, requesting that Maalim's testimony also be heard.
The National Police Service separately confirmed that Abshir and Maalim were found by members of the public at Rawana and Uran shopping centres in Marsabit County.
Police said officers from Sololo Police Station subsequently escorted the two men to the station, where their statements were recorded.
"The NPS is committed to conducting a thorough, impartial and expeditious evidence-led investigation," the police service said in a statement on Thursday.
The case now raises two separate legal questions: whether police should be restrained from arresting or prosecuting the two men, and whether state agencies have adequately accounted for their disappearance.
The court's consideration of the applications comes amid continued calls for accountability over the incident, which attracted widespread attention from Kenya's legal fraternity.
Although Abshir and Maalim have resurfaced, the circumstances surrounding their disappearance and the identities of those allegedly responsible remain unresolved.
Follow our social media pages for breaking news updates, in-depth stories and videos.
news@nairobilens.ke